- Forrester Councils
- Councils Overview
- log in
Posted by John Brand on January 8, 2013
A number of Forrester analysts from the Asia Pacific region attended the recent SAP analyst event in Singapore. Meetings with SAP global and regional executives and a large number of detailed breakout sessions over the 1½-day event all clearly indicate that SAP is continuing to try and reposition itself as a true generalized application platform player.
At the core of (almost all) initiatives is the HANA in-memory database technology. Whatever the problem, HANA will solve it (said with tongue planted very firmly in cheek). While the technology clearly has immediate performance benefits, particularly for existing SAP clients, net-new customers will likely need to compare the value of SAP’s offerings with others much more seriously.
As with any vendor, SAP has a few distinct advantages — and a few disadvantages — that go beyond the underlying technology. With its future balancing on a pivot of a change in technology focus from back-office applications to the front office and highly differentiated consumer-oriented applications (including mobility), the future for SAP is not entirely certain. But in terms of the APAC region specifically, SAPs performance to date has been nothing short of impressive. Whether SAP has the right solutions or not, and whether it provides good value for money or not, is not really in question here. SAPs strengths in the region have been to capitalize on previous sales successes and turn the old adage of “no one has ever been fired for buying IBM” into “many people will be hired when buying SAP.”
So there are a couple of key issues to take into account when looking at SAP’s future, particularly in the APAC region, and the likelihood that it can successfully reposition itself as a real platform player here. These include:
Where SAP is still trying to gain traction in APAC is with independent software vendors (ISVs). Though they do have large (and leading) players supporting the platform in APAC, these partners are rarely, if ever, tied exclusively to SAP. In fact, to this point, most are still hedging their bets. Smaller players that create multiple competing offerings in the same solution space may ultimately end up confusing the market. Worse still, they may dilute the value proposition that SAP originally bought to its customers (i.e., industry best practices and a collection of predefined application templates, data structures, and process definitions).
SAP risks becoming another “we do everything” company — yet with a platform that is neither integrated nor complete. Whereas SAP has benefited from its customers’ own organizational complexity in the past (e.g., when implementing ERP, CRM, HR, SCM, and other enterprise applications), its own technology platform complexities may now ultimately work against it. It is a big call for organizations to commit to spending even more on broadening their SAP footprint when, in some cases, they have already spent up to three-quarters of their market-capitalized value on implementing a core and "basic" SAP implementation just for finance.
So the real question is: Will organizations simply remain a customer of SAP and its core applications, or will they fully commit and make the move to “SaaP” (SAP-as-a-Platform)?
At this point, I remain fairly convinced that SAP will be successful in APAC, whether it deserves to be or not. Even where currency exchange rate and weaker economic conditions may preclude other major vendors from penetrating, SAP seems to thrive, not just survive.
SAP is increasingly a “solution looking for a problem” — but then, as our clients tell us, they often have many, many, many, problems that do need to be addressed.
Will your organization find SAP more attractive as a generalized enterprise software platform provider? Will you be making the leap from SAP to SaaP?
Save Money On Your Next Software Negotiation
Work with our software negotiation experts to save 10–20% on your next contract »
Lead BT Transformation
Develop customer-obsessed strategies to drive growth »
Forrester's CX Index
Predict how actions to improve CX will affect revenue performance.
Measure the customer experiences that matter most »