- log in
Posted by Glenn O'Donnell on September 17, 2008
One of the unfortunate legacies of management software is the still-too-universal force of exoneration as a purchase rationale. When the “blame game” kicks in, we turn to our management tools in an attempt to gather evidence that will exonerate us from blame. This is a dangerous, yet pervasive element of IT culture that must be exterminated. Perpetuation of these insidious forces will threaten the very viability of the entire organization.
IT has long been the scapegoat for everything that goes wrong in the company, and quite frankly, we deserve much of this unsavory scrutiny. The way we’ve run IT is more characteristic of sloppiness than disciplined execution. Such an atmosphere is destructive to the entire organization and this destruction is obvious to many business leaders. They will take action to remedy the situation, action that will prove disastrous for those who fail to demonstrate progress toward discipline.
First, I’ll point out a prominent root cause of this problem. It is probably painfully resonant with many of you. That root cause is the persistence of organizational fiefdoms and the inevitable attack and defense culture that festers within such an organization. We all know the “us” and “them” attitude is dangerous, yet it persists because humans tend to cluster into groups with common interests and common causes. It’s too much like teenage social cliques and these cliques nearly always become competitive with one another. As I said, it’s just human nature, nothing more, nothing less.
What happens in such a combative atmosphere is that the clique competition fosters strong offensive and defensive positions with regard to the cliques themselves. In the case of IT, a common result is the finger-pointing triggered by service outages and many other incidents. The application people blame the networking people, the server people blame the storage administrators, and so on.
These offensive tactics naturally foster defensive posturing within the cliques. Everyone puts up their shields to deflect the blame. One of the main shields in use is management software. An inordinate proportion of management tool spending over the past two decades was to support one major goal: exoneration. We’re talking tens of billions of US dollars here!
It is time to reject this common philosophy and turn to an organizational culture of cooperation. The technologies are finally emerging to help, but the highest hurdle is within us. We all have to overcome behaviors that have become so ingrained in many of us that it is now second nature; almost as involuntary as breathing! This is incredibly difficult. Don’t underestimate the effort it will take to break from one institutionalized behavior to another that is radically different. This is the real challenge of IT.
When faced with a common enemy, foes join forces. Do not view your IT colleagues as foes. We are all united in combat against the common enemies. Those enemies are poor service and ourselves. The cartoonist Walt Kelly penned the now iconic quote “We have met the enemy and he is us.” in a 1971 Pogo cartoon. How ironic it is that a comic strip reference has become a poignant battle cry for IT 37 years later.
Management tools need to synchronize with the shift in philosophy and the attack on the common enemies. We can fight the common enemy of poor service by refocusing tools on process improvement. Process improvement eliminates wasted effort and helps ensure optimum service quality. An even better side effect is that a process focus brings people together for the common cause.
Process improvement is not just process. It is not just technology. It is not just people. It is both people and technology executing according to process definitions that are proven through years of refinement by the worldwide IT community. When bright people follow good processes, they will execute well. Add the right automation to that execution and they will execute well with speed, agility, and accuracy. These are the hallmarks of good service. These are the traits that will transform the IT organization into heroes of the business. These are the qualities that nurture goodwill among IT peers and the business, where IT is a true business contributor, not a necessary evil.
By leveraging the right tools in the right way to automate by process instead of technology silos, we have a potent weapon against internal discord. When we do this right, there is no need for exoneration. Anyone who tries to adhere to the destructive practices of self-defense in such a venerable organization will find themselves vilified and expelled. A well-run operation will spit out the bad apples. Charles Darwin was right about natural selection – at least in its application to organizational dynamics!
What are your thoughts? We would love to hear your comments and tales of your own battles.
Check out Glenn's research.
Search Forrester's Blogs
Forrester Insights for iPhone
Key research and data points when and where you need them »
Lead BT Transformation
Develop customer-obsessed strategies to drive growth »
Forrester's CX Index
Predict how actions to improve CX will affect revenue performance.
Measure the customer experiences that matter most »
- Amy DeMartine (7)
- Andre Kindness (31)
- Christian Kane (5)
- Christopher Voce (8)
- Dave Bartoletti (26)
- David Johnson (52)
- Doug Washburn (37)
- Eveline Oehrlich (16)
- Frank Liu (10)
- Glenn O'Donnell (29)
- Jean-Pierre Garbani (13)
- JP Gownder (109)
- Laura Koetzle (1)
- Lauren Nelson (11)
- Michele Pelino (5)
- Naveen Chhabra (2)
- Richard Fichera (149)
- Robert Stroud (7)
- Sophia Vargas (7)
- Stephanie Balaouras (1)