Posted by Andy Hoar on June 9, 2011
Recently two colleagues of mine, Patti Freeman Evans and Martin Gill, put their respective cities’ shopping meccas to the multichannel test. The question: To what extent were bricks and mortar retailers on Fifth Ave in New York and Oxford Street in London using their physical stores to advertise and promote their digital channels?
Eager not to be left out...and curious to see how my city of Chicago would fare…I paid a visit to our world famous “Magnificent Mile” to see if/how bricks and mortar retailers promoted a connection to their own digital channels.
As I walked both sides of Michigan Ave (home to retailers such as Northface, Macys and Gap…as well as high-end retailers such as Tiffanys, Louis Vuitton, and Chanel)…I thought to myself, would Chicago be different from London and New York? Would America’s heartland have a better feel for a large and growing number of shoppers today who may physically “be” in stores but whose shopping “attention” may reside elsewhere?
- Traditional Brands Disappointed. Count among this grouphigh-end/luxury brands and more established brands (e.g. Louis Vuitton, Macys). Which is not to say that all youth-oriented brands excelled (e.g. Zara, Disney)…in fact, a surprising number of them failed to show their multichannel chops (e.g. no URLS in store, no discernable mobile presence). For example, The Disney Store was heavily promoting the “Cars 2” movie on monitors in its store, but I could not find any links anywhere to their content-rich website.
- Links to own website: In most of these stores, I didn’t see the company’s very own URL displayed anywhere. And anything online they DID promote in store was invariably relegated to low-traffic areas (near the back elevator nobody uses, on a window facing into the alley, etc).
- Mobile/Social: nothing visible in store
- Lifestyle Brands Impressed. Retailers such as Northface, Columbia Sportswear, Apple, and Nike made a clear effort to coordinate the complementary strengths of their digital and offline channels.
- Links to own website: URLs were displayed in prominent areas of the store (e.g. checkout, customer service, etc.). Eddie Bauer even allowed shoppers to use an in-store kiosk to order online at eddiebauer.com.
- Mobile/Social: Northface has a partnership with Facebook Places to reward shoppers for “checking in.” Columbia Sportswear featured QR codes throughout its stores. Apple allowed customers to operate both within the physical world of their stores (e.g. mobile apps training sessions in their in-house theater) and the virtual world (e.g. surf the web from any device in the store). Niketown encouraged shoppers to visit its website for training tips. All prominently displayed physical “community” bulletin boards in store.
Bottom Line: Mixed results. Most bricks and mortar retailers along the Mag Mile projected the image (explicitly or implicitly) that they viewed their own digital channels as competitive. On the other hand, the avowed lifestyle brands positioned their digital and offline channels as complementary (with the digital channel often serving as a source of information to help sell product in store).
For those retailers not actively promoting their digital channels in their bricks and mortar stores, it’s a missed opportunity to reach younger audiences and more tech-savvy customers – both of which represent significant purchasing power and possess influential social media referral value. Moreover, an increasing number of shoppers have now come to expect cross-channel integration as a matter of course and view those who do not provide such capability as laggards.
Which begs the question…given all that we know and accept now about consumer behavior across channels (see Welcome To The Era Of Agile Commerce by Brian Walker) why is it the case that some brands (here lifestyle brands) see the opportunity inherent in promoting digital channels while others just don’t?
Related Forrester Research
search forrester's blogs
- Andrew Stockwell (15)
- Andy Hoar (11)
- Benjamin Ensor (33)
- Bill Doyle (2)
- Carrie Johnson (21)
- Catherine Graeber (1)
- Denée Carrington (4)
- Ellen Carney (9)
- Julie Ask (93)
- Kelland Willis (3)
- Martin Gill (36)
- Patti Freeman Evans (22)
- Peter Sheldon (19)
- Peter Wannemacher (12)
- Sucharita Mulpuru (52)
- Tiffani Montez (10)
- Zia Daniell Wigder (42)